Disparities in CSA enforcement found

Disparities in CSA enforcement found

The American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) recently released ­findings from a study it conducted, which revealed that state enforcement disparities create uneven safety playing fields for carriers that have different ­operating patterns and mileage exposure in the lower 48 states. It also discovered that there are different priorities and violation issuance rates across states that dramatically undermine the uniformity of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s Compliance, Safety and Accountability (CSA) program, which is supposedly a standardized safety assessment program. However, ATRI discovered that just by simply crossing into an adjoining state, carrier basic scores can change markedly.

For example, ATRI’s model calculated one carrier’s hours-of-service (HOS) percentile decreasing by 4.2 points, but their Vehicle Maintenance percentile increasing by 12.2 points if state violation rates were normalized. Finally, based on two nationally recognized violation lists most closely associated with future crash risk, ATRI’s research documents considerable variability in state emphasis on those violations that generate the greatest safety benefit.

Research findings generate from four specific tasks:

  • State Data Metrics Compendium, which compares and contrasts several dozen safety and operational metrics for the lower 48 states;
  • Relating Violations to Crash Risk Analysis reveals that while certain violations have a stronger relationship to crash risk, these violations may not be equitably emphasized across states;
  • State Enforcement Objective Case Studies evaluate the impact of six specific state enforcement priorities on actual safety outcomes; and
  • Carrier Case Studies quantify the impact of state enforcement disparities on specific motor carrier safety measures within the Safety Measurement System (SMS), based on an ATRI-developed model that assesses the impact that standardizing state enforcement activities would have on SMS scores across seven carriers.

According to Brett Sant, Knight Transportation’s vice president of safety and risk management and a member of ATRI’s Research Advisory Committee, “ATRI’s study unequivocally quantifies what we know is a serious defect in the CSA scoring system ­that carrier safety performance as represented by BASIC scores can be dramatically impacted by the states in which a carrier operates based on nothing more than the states’ varying enforcement priorities. Until these disparities are rectified, peer-based comparisons within CSA’s scoring system will continue to be flawed and of little value as a tool for monitoring carrier and driver safety performance unless accounted for properly.”

A copy of the study results is available at the ATRI website.

You May Also Like

Decisiv adds SRM Sentinel Managed Care to TICO Edge

According to Decisiv, the new addition to the service management platform lets customers to proactively meet service needs and improve uptime.

Decisiv-TICO-TMC-2024-Dick-Hyatt

Decisiv Inc., a provider of Service Relationship Management (SRM) solutions, announced at the TMC 2024 Annual Meeting, that its Decisiv SRM Sentinel Managed Care application has been added to the TICO Edge platform. Decisiv says the addition of SRM Sentinel allows the manufacturer’s dealer network, customers and the TICO Uptime Center to collaborate in real-time for service and repairs.

Beyond standard TPMS: The crucial role of customizable tire health alerts

Delving into the shortcomings of standard TPMS and why customizable tire health alerts are crucial for commercial vehicle fleets.

Driving for Alabama: A family affair

The stories of two truck drivers for ’80s country hitmakers Alabama.

Photos by Amazing Grace Photography
So you want to write for Fleet Equipment?

Of course you do. As the premiere online publication for the heavy-duty truck market, charting the latest in trucking equipment, technology, and service trends, Fleet Equipment has a knack for digging up the stories behind the stories (while having a lot of fun along the way). Now you can be a part of it! But

Write for Fleet Equipment
Babcox Media mourns the passing of Tim Fritz, longtime editor and friend

Babcox Media Editor Tim Fritz passed away on Feb. 23 from a heart attack. He was 53 years old. Related Articles – Debating the merits of ethanol – Why isn’t a truck’s appearance part of the PM process? – Change is coming to U.S. energy policies Tim joined Babcox Media in 1990 and spent 31

Tim-Fritz-1400x700

Other Posts

Noregon announces ZF tractor, trailer telematics collaboration

The two companies demonstrated an early version of the paired telematics collaboration at the TMC 2024 Annual Meeting.

Noregon-TMC-ZF-partnership-telematics
The new Volvo VNL’s connectivity aims to boost productivity, streamline maintenance

Real-time fleet monitoring, remote updates, and extended service intervals for optimized truck performance.

Volvo-connectivity-service-TMC-1400
Pressure Systems International introduces new Geotab Marketplace offering

TireView LIVE integrates with Geotab, providing real-time tire monitoring, analytics and tire management.

PSI-TireViewLive-Geotab-TMC
Serjon highlights cybersecurity training as tech connects trucks

After successful attacks on large fleets, Serjon says it’s important to keep all employees trained on detecting cybersecurity threats.

Trailer Telematics-cybersecurity-attacks-hacking-safety