Tire decisions: Deep rubber vs. shallow rubber

Tire decisions: Deep rubber vs. shallow rubber

Low rolling resistance (LRR) tires have been a frequent topic of conversation among fleets recently. Back when the cost of fuel was closing in on $4 per gallon, fuel MPG became the focal point, and everyone seemed to go crazy and focus on fuel alone. With the advent of LRR tires and Smartway, the focus has shifted to tires. When you couple this with the cost of tires and recaps, fleet managers seem to focus more on cost rather than the amount of rubber width and tread depth. There is no question that under perfect conditions, LRR tires have an effect on using less fuel, but that should not be the only consideration. Here are a few factors that fleet managers should keep in mind when deciding between tires with deep or shallow rubber.

Deep Rubber

For the most part, tires with deep rubber will run longer, and although deep rubber has a negative effect on fuel economy, the positive side is longer life, less debris penetration, less visits for flat tires and casing protection. Many of the top CSA issues are less than 2/32nds rubber—deeper rubber could help.

As for tractor drive axle positions, traction design tires with deep lugs, this helps with traction, life and wards off uncontrollable road debris and reduces flat tires. This also helps with traction during inclement weather. This helps the drivers’ attitude when it comes to perceived traction. Deep rubber also does give you a little squirrelly feeling when new at 32/32nds and possibly some heel and toe wear with high horsepower and automated transmission. Deep rubber also would be considered less desirable when it comes to LRR and fuel economy. Deep rubber drive recaps should also be considered for all the same reasons, and cap cost should be looked at as cost per 32nds and not the cost of the cap by itself.

Shallow Rubber

Shallow rubber has generally been fleets’ default choice for trailer positions, due to the lower expense and benefits when it comes to low rolling resistance and irregular wear. Also, shallow trailer tires will not be stolen in the drop yard. Shallow rubber on trailers quickly go from 11/32nds to 2/32nds for most fleets do not align trailer axles and before you realize it, CSA has got you. I still suggest deep 22/nds rubber especially for regional non-drop yard type operations. When recapped, deep rubber becomes the better choice again, drop yards or no.

As for tractor tires, most steer axle applications are 18/32nd and feature less rubber and less wear, are easier to balance, and are designed to limit front axle wear. I still suggest deeper 22/32nd rubber on the steer axle.

Conclusion

LRR tires certainly will bring some fuel savings when tested on a complete unit. The savings will also show on a tractor, but are much harder to measure. LRR tires are shallower and have a softer designed rubber compound which means, in my mind, less wear and more visits to the shop for replacement. Shallower rubber means more road calls and LRR tires seem to command a higher cost—tire manufacturers want a piece of the savings for engineering ROI.

In my 40 years of fleet management, I have been a proponent of deep rubber, even when I was criticized by my peers for many reasons—it was not a fashionable choice; heavy rubber causes cap failures; they go out of balance; etc. My reasons were simple: more is better. Now it seems that time has proven that the cost per mile for tires and fuel savings are at a cross road of measured value. LRR tires do have their place, I just have not found the place where the data supports the choice. I still pull tires earlier than most, 5-6 32nds, preferably at PM time.

In conclusion, these are my top ten factors for making decisions on tires:

  1. Customer service and on-time deliveries
  2. Driver’s hours of service
  3. Reduced road calls and downtime
  4. Potential road debris penetration
  5. Cost per 32nds
  6. Removal at PM time
  7. Tread design on new and recaps
  8. Local service and support
  9. Brand support
  10. Last, maybe least: LRR and fuel.

Make the best choice for your fleet and don’t let the cost of fuel alone control the decision.

For more information, visit darrystuart.com or email comments, questions or requests to Darry at: [email protected].

You May Also Like

FE’s February Fab 5 truck trends

Maintenance vs. buying new: We weigh the costly pros and cons of keeping your fleet running.

Fleet-Equipment-February-Top-5-truck-warranties-electric-maintenance-engines-volvo-vnl

Well, we made it to March. In like a lion, for some of us, but I'm ready to just lay down like a lamb and nap until it's nice enough to go play outside (note: despite what you just read, I am not a dog). The winter doldrums are in full swing, and I've finally gotten around to doing some projects both around the house and on my car, which got me thinking about the importance of maintenance. Let's dive into Fleet Equipment's top five articles from February, with a focus on keeping things running, and the new tech you might use to replace something if it's too far gone.

Freightliner M2, SD Plus Series launch updates its medium-duty truck offering

Freightliner introduced the new Plus Series–enhanced versions of its M2 and SD models, including the M2 106 Plus, M2 112 Plus, 108SD Plus, and 114SD Plus. The enhanced models provide a major update to the interior and electrical systems of the M2 and SD models. The OEM noted that the Plus Series is designed to

Freightliner-MD-SD-Plus-Series-1400
Truck cruise control technology that looks at the road ahead

If you’ve ever visited the Northeast region of the country, you’ve most likely encountered intimidating terrain. The winding roads. The steep hills. The intricate routes that challenge any seasoned driver, and, most recently, advanced cruise control systems that aim to improve fuel efficiency and driver comfort.   Related Articles – Four ways A.I. can help cut

Four ways A.I. can help cut diesel fuel costs

The fluctuation of fuel prices has made it more challenging to operate day-to-day. Drivers get paid by the mile, and, when fuel costs go up, margins shrink, impacting how fleets profit and pay their employees. Intelligent technology can lessen the impact of high prices by improving overall fuel efficiency. Related Articles – New ways to

trucking-technology-hacking
Peterbilt GM Jason Skoog charts today’s truck support, tomorrow’s truck solutions

Peterbilt made headlines recently when it became the first major North American OEM to open orders for an electric truck, the Peterbilt 220EV. In this exclusive interview, Peterbilt General Manager and PACCAR Vice President Jason Skoog details the technology investments that are keeping fleets productive during this year’s trying pandemic and laying the groundwork for

Peterbilt General Manager PACCAR Technology Electric Truck

Other Posts

Double Coin FR610, other tires to be displayed at MATS

The FR610 is the latest SmartWay Verified long haul steer tire in Double Coin’s lineup.

Double-coin-logo-truck-tire-generic
Cummins at HELM of fuel agnostic engines in ‘Leap Ahead’ event

The fuel agnostic Cummins X15 engine was the crown jewel of the event, which also highlighted the company’s HELM initiative.

Cummins-x15-x15n-engines
Navistar delivers first International LT Series with S13 integrated powertrain to fleets

Navistar says the International S13 Integrated Powertrain is the most fuel-efficient one the company offers.

Love's-Delivery-Navistar-International-s13-integrated-powertrain
Cummins to launch big bore natural gas engine

Limited production of the Cummins X15N starts this spring and full production will begin this summer.

2024-cummins-X15N-Fuel-Agnostic-engine