Alternate energy source scorecard

Alternate energy source scorecard

The alternate energy world can be confusing. To help us all better get our minds around recent developments, I created a simplistic tabulation for first and second generation sources with which I am familiar.


Pros: It removes CO2 from atmosphere, no sulfur, less CO, CO2 and HC, 80% of energy of crude oil, 10 to 100 times better yield than competitors, uses untillable land and doesn’t compete with food crops.
Cons: It’s currently too expensive and several years from commercialization.


Pros: It’s a proven technology, equivalent mileage to diesel and readily available.
Cons: Its cold temperature performance and fraudulent RINs.

Electricity (battery & plug-in)

Pros: It’s a proven technology, provides 100% torque at startup and has the lowest operating cost.
Cons: Its high initial cost, weight/range limitations and battery replacement costs.

Ethanol (corn-based)

Pros: It’s a proven technology and farmers and Big Ag love it.
Cons: Its terrible fuel economy, more GHG emissions and corrosion issues.

Dimethyl Ether

Pros: It’s made from coal or natural gas, reduces CO, NOx and PM, sulfur-free, doesn’t compete with food crops and offers a high cetane number.
Cons: Its cost and it needs further development.


Pros: Its energy density is 98% of gasoline, doesn’t absorb water, natural product of fermentation and sulfur free.
Cons: Its cost and needs further development.

Natural Gas

Pros: Its cost, reduced emissions and extensive proven reserves.
Cons: Its high initial cost, it lacks infrastructure and requires maintenance training.

I’ve completely written off corn-based ethanol because of all its problems. Cellulosic ethanol makes more sense, but development work is necessary prior to commercialization. Corrosion is always present with alcohol fuels.

Electrical power only makes sense in niche applications because of its weight and range limitations, but it is not zero emissions. Still, 60% of our electrical power is generated by coal—one of the dirtiest fuels. Rare earth batteries catch fire when exposed to water.Biodiesel is more promising because of its energy density, and I think its future will look brighter when fuels such as dimethyl ether and isobutanol are further developed and commercialized. To me, algae is the obvious choice for alternate power for commercial users in the long term. Algae is effective, and it doesn’t compete with food crops for tillable lands. We’ll all be “green” eventually, but it will take several years.

In the near term, I prefer biodiesel/clean diesel or LNG for high-mileage trucking and natural gas for everything else. The problem with plant-based biodiesel and/or clean diesel fuels is volume. We use a lot of distillate fuel for aircraft, home heating, industry and transportation. Currently, biodiesel production is sufficient to meet transportation and consumer needs, but total biodiesel usage will be limited by production capacity. Also, cold weather issues limit more widespread biodiesel acceptance. We’ve uncovered an over 50-year supply of natural gas reserves, so the low cost of natural gas should be sustainable. Big Oil will support natural gas, so that eases infrastructure issues.

Do you get the impression that I prefer natural gas?

You May Also Like

Weather Guard adds new truck boxes and headache racks

The 2024 Saddle and Lo-Side truck boxes include the one-key Ultralock security feature.


Work truck equipment manufacturer Weather Guard has introduced new truck boxes and headache racks. The 2024 Saddle and Lo-Side truck boxes include the one-key Ultralock security feature, which Weather Guard says combines maximum security protection, ability to manage keys to multiple boxes and new visual locking cues. A new red push button lock mechanism lets end-users know at a glance if the box is locked or not—if the red button is popped up, the box is unlocked.

Beyond standard TPMS: The crucial role of customizable tire health alerts

Delving into the shortcomings of standard TPMS and why customizable tire health alerts are crucial for commercial vehicle fleets.

Driving for Alabama: A family affair

The stories of two truck drivers for ’80s country hitmakers Alabama.

Photos by Amazing Grace Photography
So you want to write for Fleet Equipment?

Of course you do. As the premiere online publication for the heavy-duty truck market, charting the latest in trucking equipment, technology, and service trends, Fleet Equipment has a knack for digging up the stories behind the stories (while having a lot of fun along the way). Now you can be a part of it! But

Write for Fleet Equipment
Babcox Media mourns the passing of Tim Fritz, longtime editor and friend

Babcox Media Editor Tim Fritz passed away on Feb. 23 from a heart attack. He was 53 years old. Related Articles – Debating the merits of ethanol – Why isn’t a truck’s appearance part of the PM process? – Change is coming to U.S. energy policies Tim joined Babcox Media in 1990 and spent 31


Other Posts

A ‘Toward Zero’ emissions Q&A with Volvo Trucks’s Roger Alm

Talking through the challenges, the technological advances, and the strategies for a sustainable future.

Peterbilt offers Cummins X15N natural gas engine in Models 579, 567, 520

Orders are scheduled for production in Q3 of this year.

NACFE: natural gas sits in ‘messy middle’

The organization believes RNG to be a good fuel for fleets looking to decarbonize now, but expects some companies may hold out for BEVs.

SmithCo adds Arizona, Minnesota dealer network members

Adding the new dealers now makes SmithCo side dump trailers available in Arizona, Minnesota and Wisconsin.