Cautious optimism about biodiesel

Cautious optimism about biodiesel

One of the privileges of being old is that I can be a bit of a curmudgeon. So, this month I’d like to pick on biodiesel a little.

One of the privileges of being old is that I can be a bit of a curmudgeon. So, this month I’d like to pick on biodiesel a little.

Now, please don’t take this wrong; I’m a 100-percent-committed supporter of biodiesel/ULSD fuel blends. But, lately, I’ve seen article after article promoting biodiesel as the solution to all of our problems – from emissions reductions to dependency on foreign sources of crude oil. I’ve even seen testimonials from truck drivers stating that biodiesel is “awesome.“

Excuse me…shouldn’t scientists – not farmers, politicians, truck drivers, or anyone else – tell us what biodiesel can and cannot do?

Let’s inject a healthy dose of realism into the biodiesel discussion. Biodiesel is not quite ready for center stage. There are some issues and limitations that must be addressed first. Europe has done a lot of the early work for us, but we still have much to do.

For one thing, the absence of a national biodiesel specification makes me a little uncomfortable. Do you recall Minnesota’s recent problems with biodiesel that were ultimately linked to faulty biodiesel production methods? In our exuberance, every state wants to issue its own specifications, but long-haul truckers need consistency across the nation to make biodiesel practical. Let’s ask our politicians to worry less about getting re-elected and worry more about what’s good for this country.

There are also some serious issues about biodiesel concentrations in diesel fuel blends. Diesel engine builders have urged us to be careful with blends containing more than 5 percent biodiesel. I just reviewed a Society of Automotive Engineers paper that contained data on biodiesel concentrations of greater than 25 percent in diesel fuel. The paper, by the University of Birmingham (UK) and Jaguar Cars, found that higher biodiesel concentrations did indeed reduce CO2 and PM emissions, but NOx emissions increased significantly. Even increasing EGR rates could not restore NOx emissions. On a positive note, this data suggests that the engine was actually operating more efficiently!

As stated in my January column, if all of the arable land in the world is used in the production of renewable fuels, our dependence on crude oil would only be reduced 4 to 5 percent. Or, if we emphasize C02 emissions, we might expect to double that number to 9 to 10 percent. Our scientists need to be investigating other sources of renewable fuels, many of which might produce more energy than corn or soy beans.

Let me give you an example. We know the tremendous support corn-based ethanol has received in farming states. In southwestern Missouri, where I live, we recently had a major ice storm. You wouldn’t believe the number of trees the storm destroyed! So, we are busily cleaning up the debris and trimming the trees. Mountains of limbs and entire trees have been gathered. Now, we are burning them! What a waste! Shouldn’t we be trying to produce ethanol or methanol from them as a renewable fuel?

The National Biodiesel Board (NBB) recently cautioned its members that powerful oil and gas interests have been lobbying politicians for a tax credit when they blend biomass into refineries’ petroleum streams. The NBB says these interests are asking the Federal government to pay them $1 for every gallon of biomass (e.g., cooking oil) they use in refineries. This would provide refiners with a windfall profit that requires no in-vestment in new refining capacity. Of course, the NBB is against this tax credit, since it would result in competitive pressure on biodiesel produced from farm crops.

I want our legislators to put the needs of our nation ahead of their other priorities and let the scientists determine how to produce biodiesel (and ethanol and methanol) and how much to blend in fuel to provide the best performance with the lowest exhaust emissions. Is that too much to ask?

You May Also Like

The 7 EV battery lessons we learned at ACT Expo

Battery experts weigh in on long-life vs. high-density, the residual value of older EVs, ethically sourcing EV battery materials and more.


For some fleets, adopting their first electric trucks might feel like taking a leap of faith simply because there are so many unknowns – many of which revolve around the true viability of the electric powertrain. What will the next generation of battery chemistries bring to trucking? Will the new electric truck you buy today hold its value better than a new diesel truck would five or 10 years down the road? How can we give higher consideration to ethics issues on the path to more sustainable operations?

Thermo King introduces the third-gen. TriPac Auxiliary Power Unit

The company says the third-generation TriPac APU is available in two different models to help customers meet emission regulations.

Western Global offers transportable, on-site refueling tank

The TransCube can be stacked up to three high when empty and two high when full.

Carrier Transicold debuts Supra eCool electric truck refrigeration unit series

The company notes that the Supra e9 and e11 units will provide comparable refrigeration performance to its diesel-powered predecessor.

The keys to properly securing unique cargo

With the wide range of cargo types, unique materials and geometric shapes and the significant mass of some loads, there is a lot to consider.


Other Posts

Cargo securement tips for International Roadcheck 2023

A brief educational triage to help you refresh your memory on proper cargo securement before International Roadcheck 2023.

Cummins, Accelera emphasize decarbonization, hydrogen at ACT Expo

The company showcased technologies including electrolyzers to produce hydrogen that can power both a hydrogen-fueled internal combustion engine concept truck and a fuel cell electric powertrain.

Hyliion unveils Karno electric range extender powertrain at ACT Expo

The Karno technology is a linear motor heat generator that leverages 3D metal-printed components and proprietary flameless oxidation technology to produce clean electricity.

Dana introduces Spicer Electrified e-Transmissions for commercial vehicles

Dana says the powertrain accommodates a diverse range of medium-duty applications, such as straight trucks, walk-in vans, refuse trucks, utility trucks and platform trucks.