CSA report card

CSA report card

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s (FMCSA) Compliance, Safety and Accountability (CSA) initiative is still a thorn in the paw for the trucking industry. One of the reasons is that shippers have become more selective of the carriers they hire and are requesting both the publicly and non-publicly available Behavior Analysis & Safety Improvement Categories (BASIC) scores under CSA. For example, a 2012 study by the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) found that 27.6% of shippers had terminated existing contracts with carriers based on their BASIC scores. Furthermore, 50% of shippers noted that poor BASIC scores have deterred them from entering into contracts with new customers even though FMCSA states that BASIC scores do not constitute actual safety ratings. Having shippers use BASIC scores as carrier selection criteria is potentially harmful to carriers’ business operations since ATRI found inverse relationships between collision involvement and carrier BASIC scores in the Driver Fitness and Controlled Substances/Alcohol BASICs.

CSA remains a major concern within the trucking industry as noted by its continued top or near-top ranking in ATRI’s “Top 10” critical issues research over the past three years. Of particular concern to the industry is the relationship between specific BASICs and crash risk, the lack of crash accountability, the need for more transparency in the development of the BASICs, and the severity weightings assigned to the violations.

ATRI states that more recently, attention has focused on the disparate enforcement of the number and type of violations issued across states and the potential impact this has on carrier BASIC scores. For example, Transcore Freight Solutions identified that nine of the top 10 states with the highest percentage of carrier alerts for the Vehicle Maintenance BASIC are contiguous and in the south. In another example, Vigillo analyzed 2012 violation data from the Motor Carrier Management Information System (MCMIS). Researchers at Vigillo found that at the national level, on average there were approximately 11.97 light violations for every one speeding violation. State-level comparisons reveal that in Texas, there are 321.02 light violations for every speeding violation, and in Indiana, there are 1.91 light violations for every one speeding violation. These patterns of enforcement activity present a possible issue for carriers as their BASIC scores may not be wholly reflective of their safety performance, but rather a representation of the enforcement objectives within the states in which they operate.

As stated by FMCSA, the goal of CSA is to create an efficient and effective nationwide safety initiative among its federal and state enforcement partners. This may be a difficult task since previous research conducted by ATRI suggests that uniformity is lacking in the amount and type of CSA training received by enforcement personnel. Among the study’s findings, nearly three-quarters of enforcement personnel noted a need for increased CSA training and education, with approximately one-tenth of participants never receiving any form of CSA training as of 2012.

ATRI is now investigating the correlation between CSA training (content and quantity) and test scores, as well as the relationship between CSA perceptions, knowledge and carrier “safety culture.” Additionally, the findings from the enforcement personnel knowledge test provide a foundation for future evaluation of these individuals’ knowledge of CSA and how that knowledge impacts enforcement activities.

One of the biggest frustrations for fleets remains: While they can properly maintain vehicles and train drivers to avoid CSA citations, they have no control over the variables related to law enforcement.

This column appeared in the February 2014 edition of Fleet Equipment. You can read the entire issue on your phone or tablet by downloading the Fleet Equipment app.

You May Also Like

Peterbilt GM Jason Skoog charts today’s truck support, tomorrow’s truck solutions

Peterbilt made headlines recently when it became the first major North American OEM to open orders for an electric truck, the Peterbilt 220EV. In this exclusive interview, Peterbilt General Manager and PACCAR Vice President Jason Skoog details the technology investments that are keeping fleets productive during this year’s trying pandemic and laying the groundwork for

Peterbilt General Manager PACCAR Technology Electric Truck

Peterbilt made headlines recently when it became the first major North American OEM to open orders for an electric truck, the Peterbilt 220EV. In this exclusive interview, Peterbilt General Manager and PACCAR Vice President Jason Skoog details the technology investments that are keeping fleets productive during this year's trying pandemic and laying the groundwork for the electric trucks that Peterbilt aims to start rolling off the line by the end of the year. Click the story above to read.

What’s behind the slow adoption of FA-4 oil?

Introduced three years ago, the American Petroleum Institute (API)’s CK-4 and FA-4 oil categories were billed as the next generation of oil, improving on the engine protection and fuel economy benefits offered by previous engine oil categories.

Slow-Adoption-Oil-800x400
How will today’s ‘customer focus’ translate to tomorrow’s electric trucks?

Over the past three years, OEMs have invested heavily in driver-focused equipment benefits—from cozy creature comforts to uptime- and productivity-boosting technology. Today, significant R&D investment is going into the development of electric trucks—probing the possibilities of untested powertrains in hopes of producing a product that meets application needs.

Volvo-electric-truck-VNR-800x400
Benchmarking success: Utility fleets are using performance metrics to drive measurable improvements

Fleet executives at the annual Electric Utility Fleet Managers Conference (EUFMC), discussed benchmarking. For fleet managers on the panel, using data and performance metrics is a means of showing opportunities for improvement, through which cost savings can be realized.

International-800x400
Sleeper supremacy: A focus on the customer has led to more fleets spec’ing large, decked-out sleepers

Across the business world, companies are becoming more and more interested in emulating the success of Amazon. It’s a model that many truck OEMs are now following as they sharpen their focus on fleet customers, learn what equipment will meet the customers’ needs and deliver the products that they want.

Peterbilt-sleeper-800x400

Other Posts

ATRI: Carriers experience excessive rates from predatory truck towing

ATRI’s report examines the causes and countermeasures of predatory heavy-duty towing

Predatory-Towing-Cover-Image-1400
ATRI: Fuel costs top the list of trucking industry issues

The American Transportation Research Institute recently released its 18th annual Top Industry Issues report, identifying the leading industry concerns including fuel prices, the driver shortage, truck parking, driver compensation, the economy and for the first time, speed limiters. Related Articles – Volvo changes truck spec’ing with new VNL – Power Heavy Duty adds Childers Auto

Diesel-Gas-Pump-Truck
ATRI-developed assessment tool used to ID safe, younger drivers

The American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) has released the results of the Phase 1 Beta Test of its Younger Driver Assessment Tool. This is the second in a series of technical memoranda from ATRI exploring the potential for an assessment tool to identify the safest drivers among 18- to 20-year-olds. Related Articles – Hexagon Agility

truck driver safety training technology
Technology to mitigate skyrocketing insurance premiums

While the social and economic impacts of the pandemic have been front and center this year, insurance has remained a top concern among fleet leaders in 2020. In its annual report, the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) listed insurance cost and availability as the fifth most pressing issue facing trucking. In fact, ATRI’s annual Operational

Digital Dollars trucking data value