Fleeting performance: Should you repair or replace your heavy-duty truck?

Fleeting performance: Should you repair or replace your heavy-duty truck?

Should the Data Center team repair or replace the vehicle causing them problems? You decide.

We’ve come to a fork in the road and honestly, both options make sense when it comes to where we go from here. So here’s the plan. We’re both going to present our defending arguments, and then you decide. Should we repair or replace?

We’ve had this truck for almost 5 years, it’s got about 450,000 miles on it. When it’s running, it’s great, but when it’s not, we always have a diagnostic mystery on our hands. Nothing seems to keep that check engine light at bay for long.

Identifying the root cause can take some time, but maybe instead of starting from scratch, we could try to repair it again. 450,000 miles is a lot, but with the technology we have these days and a consistent and recurring preventative maintenance schedule, it could go much further. Besides, obtaining a new truck is easier said than done these days.

Considering age, preventive maintenance, miles driven and duty cycles, we still find ourselves kind of stumped between risk and potential. What are some other factors that fleet operators should consider when deciding between repairing and replacing? And what are some best practices for making this decision to optimize overall fleet efficiency and profitability? Let’s turn things over to Noregon. Maybe they can shed some light on what to consider and help us figure this out.

Fleet Equipment’s Data Center is sponsored by Noregon. Subscribe to our newsletter to catch every episode as we’ll be diving into use cases, talking with the data pros and making data usage approachable.

You May Also Like

Communication is key in truck service

The goal when a truck needs a repair is the same for all parties involved: a quick, efficient repair done right.


Communication is so important when it comes to truck service. Whether your fleet works with an independent shop or dealer or has its own shop, the goal when a truck needs a repair is the same for all parties involved: a quick, efficient repair done right. For you, time your truck spends in the shop bay is time it could be running its route; for the shop, time your truck spends in the bay is time another truck could be in that bay, so it benefits everyone to move quickly.

If you’re not using VMRS, here’s what you’re missing out on

Here are a few VMRS tips that we’ve sourced from across the fleet maintenance industry.

What role could A.I. play in trucking?

There’s a lot of hyperbole out there about A.I. So let’s talk facts, and get to what role it can play in truck service shops.

The importance of ongoing technician training

Plenty of time is spent talking about the importance of training new technicians, but ongoing training is just as important.

Data Center Technician Training
How preventative maintenance can help you avoid the dreaded engine fault code

If you’re not doing the right maintenance on your trucks, you will start to get fault codes, sometimes at inopportune times.


Other Posts

Grote demonstrates 4SEE Smart Trailer System at TMC 2024

Demonstrated in a ride-along event at TMC, Grote teamed up with Stoneridge to add a new backup camera to its 4SEE system.

Phillips touts T/T Pair tractor, trailer ‘smart seven-way socket’ at TMC

The T/T Pair by Phillips aims to enhance tractor-trailer connectivity, security, and maintenance practices.

FE’s February Fab 5 truck trends

Maintenance vs. buying new: We weigh the costly pros and cons of keeping your fleet running.

Hexagon Agility expands CNG fuel system manufacturing plant

The company says a green future for trucking is close, and what’s coming next could put fears over a lack of CNG power to bed.