Lease vs. buy: Case 1

Lease vs. buy: Case 1

Leasing allows fleets to keep bank credit lines open

Ordinarily, credit allows companies to expand their business, improve efficiency and diversify their operations so they can take advantage of new business opportunities. But overall demand for business financing has waned as the economy continues to work through a deep recession. According to recent monthly surveys conducted by the National Federation of Independent Businesses, fewer of its members actually sought credit in late 2008 and early 2009. Overland park, Kan.-based petroleum marketer and transportation company, CarterEnergy, relies on its trucks and trailers to bein peak condition. All of its tractors and tankwagons are leased trhgouth MHC Truck Leasing, a locall PacLease francise.

Many banks have tightened their lending criteria even though the federal government’s Troubled Asset Relief Program provided several major U.S. banks hundreds of billions of dollars in an effort to spur more lending. According to a recent quarterly survey of U.S. bank loan officers conducted by the Federal Reserve, two-thirds of respondents reported their banks tightened lending to businesses.

“Plus, in these challenging economic times, many companies find they must use existing lines of credit to pay bills or to make payrolls as their customers take longer to pay on their accounts,” Chris Maccio, director of sales-East for PacLease, said. “Or they must have access to ready sources of credit. That ready access will allow them to take full advantage of new business opportunities quickly should stimulus efforts by governments in North America and around the world boost the global economy. Even with good credit ratings, a surprising number of businesses both large and small find that banks scrutinize their requests closely. That’s why preservation of their existing credit lines is so critical to their operations.”

As financing remains challenging, Maccio said he is seeing more companies turn to full-service truck leasing as an alternative. Full-service truck leasing like that offered by PacLease allows companies to reserve their lines of credit. It also allows them to acquire trucks equipped with the latest technology designed to save fuel, reduce emissions and enhance driver productivity.

When it comes to financing trucks, banks can be particularly reluctant since trucks can quickly depreciate in value, especially when they are not specified correctly, Maccio added. Also, since truck loan default rates are higher among owner-operators, bank loan officers tend to lump all truck loan applicants into a higher risk of default category.
“Banks tend to hesitate when it comes to trucks because they don’t know the industry as well as we do,” Maccio said.

“Our business is to understand trucks. We work with our customers and Kenworth and Peterbilt engineers to determine the best truck specifications. Our goal is to optimize a truck’s residual value and performance and minimize its operating expenses. Plus, PacLease is part of PACCAR’s financial services segment, which has total assets of $10 billion and an AA- credit rating. So, we’re well capitalized to offer any size company a variety of leasing options. That’s why a full-service lease for trucks through PacLease is so attractive.”

Olen Hunter, director of sales-West for PacLease, said before banks and lending institutions make new loans or extend additional lines of credit to businesses, they typically establish certain debt-to-equity ratio requirements. These requirements can help them feel more confident about their customers’ ability to repay their loans.

Any time a company borrows money to buy assets, such as trucks, the company must record the loan on the liability side of its balance sheets as well as the truck(s) on the asset side, Hunter said. That can impact productivity ratios or profitability ratios such as return on investment (ROI), return on assets (ROA) and return on equity (ROE). Some banks may look at a company’s ROA and ROI to determine the interest rate or premium they will charge. Investors and stockholders also look closely at ROAs and ROIs.

“Companies that borrow money should be concerned with maintaining best-in-class ROA and ROI ratios,” Hunter said. “If your company has depreciating assets, like trucks for example, and you don’t generate an improved return or profitability for each dollar you invest in those trucks, your financial ratio will be out of order not only for internal reporting, but also for all of your company’s future financial needs.”

Creditors and lenders look at ROA and ROI ratios to determine a company’s productivity and profitability. That’s important because most companies have a limited amount of capital they can borrow. If they borrow that capital to acquire trucks, then it can’t be used for projects or opportunities, Hunter said. Full-service leasing allows companies to use their leasing provider’s money to finance the trucks. That leaves companies free to use their borrowing capacity for projects or other revenue-generating endeavors.

Cost less than ownership
In a lease, the cost of the vehicle, apportioned tax and license, finance charge (set interest rate for the lease term), and calculated cost-per-mile maintenance expenses, minus the calculated residual value determine your monthly payment.
“Often, companies find that when we do a lease-own analysis in a net present-value, net after-tax format, full-service leasing from PacLease can help them reduce their operating costs after they consider the tax impact that a full-service and off-balance sheet operating lease provides,” Hunter added.

An analysis can help companies calculate how much owning and maintaining a truck fleet truly costs them down to whatever unit of measurement they need. For beverage distributors, for example, we can calculate the cost down to the per-case level. Then we can show them how the per-case cost of full-service truck leasing with PacLease compares to that of truck ownership.

“When we sit down with our customers, we ask questions to try to understand what drives their costs and then determine ways we can help them develop efficiencies in their operation through the right truck specification choices,” Hunter added. For example, PacLease sat down with a fairly large steel distribution company based out of Los Angeles and found that payload was the company’s most important measurement of success. Every pound we could take off the company’s leased truck was another pound of product they could haul to their customers. In the past, the company leased trucks from another leasing company that took more of a “one-size-fits-all” approach to their truck specification needs, he said.

“As a result of taking measurements of one of the company’s trucks, we provided the company a Peterbilt 386 with an optimized wheelbase and durable, but lighter weight components,” he added. “The optimized wheelbase and lighter weight components allowed the company to haul more steel and as a result, the company made more money with that truck.”

Hunter said, “Companies that have switched from truck ownership to leasing trucks from us have found that when PacLease maintains their trucks, their operations department can concentrate on their core business, and in many cases, improve on-time delivery rates.”

You May Also Like

Bestpass hires new executives

The new hires are expected to help Bestpass scale service offerings and network integrations for commercial fleets and owner operators. 


Bestpass, a developer of toll management and safety solutions for commercial fleets, announced two additions to its leadership team. Bestpass welcomes Scott Chao (pictured above left), as chief marketing officer and Shay Demmons (right) as chief product officer. The company says these hires will aid in its commitment to scale service offerings and network integrations for commercial fleets and owner operators. 

Ford Trucks, Irdeto announce cybersecurity partnership

Irdeto will provide Ford Trucks with a fully managed key lifecycle management service.

ServiceTitan, Thumbtack integrate job management tech

The companies say this will let local service businesses manage booking requests and cut down on time toggling between platforms.

TechCelerate Now awarded phase 2 contract

The program aims to reduce accidents by speeding up the trucking industry’s adoption of ADAS systems.

Bosch introduces RevX dispatcher optimization tool

Aiming to reduce the number of empty miles driven, Bosh says RevX enables fleets to maximize revenue by efficiently booking optimal loads.


Other Posts

BeyondTrucks, Samsara announce free integration

The companies say customers can have their real-time data connected within a few clicks at no cost.

Continental’s ContiConnect Lite to allow digital tire management for OTR tires

Continental said ContiConnect Lite helps fleet managers monitor the condition of their tires via bluetooth.

Ten5 introduces hands-free voice assistant

The company says the technology will help decrease both distracted and dangerous driving, while giving fleet managers to communicate faster.

Isaac Instruments celebrates 25 years

While marking a quarter-century in business, ISAAC instruments is also celebrating 10 years exclusively focused on helping fleets succeed.