Purchase and lease decisions: the fleet perspective

Purchase and lease decisions: the fleet perspective

When researching the optimal balance between purchasing and leasing, we asked fleets how they acquire and finance equipment. Here’s what they had to say:

Peter Nativo, director of maintenance for Oakley Transport says, “We lease short term [seasonal] trucks for our Citrus division. This year we leased 85. The season runs from the end of November to the end of May. Trailers we lease base on business and the customers commitment. We run some seasonal refer trailers and some liquid bulk trailers; 10 bulk and five refrigerated.

“As for maintenance,” he says, “our truck leases include maintenance but, we maintain the trailers on lease. The truck maintenance that is included we buy because the trucks are various brand names and we don’t want to stock allot of different parts and supplies for the trucks. The agreement includes preventive maintenance too. Leasing programs work well when you don’t want to invest your capital into equipment on a business that could be short term or seasonal. The investment into technicians and the cost of running a shop in today’s transportation environment isn’t cheap so in some operations it makes sense to lease.”

Dan Vander Pol, director of maintenance for Oak Harbor Freight Lines Inc., notes, “When we purchase trucks, we do a five year TRAC lease with a 20% residual. We always buy out the 20% residual at the end and keep the truck for longer than five years. Being LTL, we can repurpose line trucks from linehaul to pick up and delivery, which extends the useful life of the truck. We have never done a full maintenance lease. We have seven shop facilities and most of the time we are able to run the trucks through our own shops.

“When I have taken a look at full maintenance leases, I have found that our cost per mile is lower when maintaining the truck ourselves. I would think that it would be useful to do a full maintenance lease when opening up a new market where we do not have a shop yet, but we have never tried it.”

Darry Stuart, president and chief executive officer of DWS fleet management services, adds, “Leasing vehicles has been and still is a strong alternative—especially since engine emission changes. It allows the bigger fleets to predict and build into their rates a straight line cost for budgeting. Straight-line costs, which may not be the best financial deal, are easier to plan and some times planning is more important than the best low cost option. Some companies are prepared for higher easier predictive planning, but I suggest caution since straight line pricing does not include unpredictable costs. There are other considerations such as, operational, damage, accidents or driver-related add-ons that affect the leasing invoice.”

He goes on to say that there are many things to look for when financing and leasing, for instance, schedule “A” vehicle value, depreciation calculations, consumer price index increases, what is entailed in the contract, replacements, how many vehicle replacements and contract length. Then you need to consider turn-in conditions. Some leases require that vehicles be turned in brand new condition, without consideration to reasonable wear and tear.

As for spec’ing power vehicles, Stuart believes, “The larger leasing companies have it down: There maybe a few special items, but the specs are pretty good and may include components that provide lower costs savings. The most important thing to consider when leasing is the service, location and then price.
However, for finance lease options, most of what has been said above does not apply, since the transaction is just a method of financing. Fleets are locked into the contract requirements and may not have much ability or experience to spec and purchase the most desirable piece of equipment. These days, with vertical integration, the choices are pretty much gone.

“As for leasing trailers, most of the specs are generic and are good for overall industry application—not really specific to the application unless a specific need is negotiated and there is a close working relationship between the fleet and the leasing company. But when you bid the trailers. For full service leasing, the same rules apply, but be cautious make sure you understand what you are contracting. I recommend that fleets consider engaging a third party facilitator or negotiator who can provide good advice.”

You May Also Like

Navistar releases decarbonization update in 2023 sustainability report

Navistar said the report also looks at its commitment to sustainability through environmental initiatives, human rights due diligence and more.


Navistar recently shared its 2023 Sustainability Report, which the company says highlights how it is "accelerating the impact of sustainable mobility with its main area of strategic focus on decarbonization." Navistar said the report also shines a light on how the company is solidifying its commitment to sustainability through circular business practices, social impact and environmental compliance initiatives, human rights due diligence, and diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts.

Freightliner M2, SD Plus Series launch updates its medium-duty truck offering

Freightliner introduced the new Plus Series–enhanced versions of its M2 and SD models, including the M2 106 Plus, M2 112 Plus, 108SD Plus, and 114SD Plus. The enhanced models provide a major update to the interior and electrical systems of the M2 and SD models. The OEM noted that the Plus Series is designed to

Truck cruise control technology that looks at the road ahead

If you’ve ever visited the Northeast region of the country, you’ve most likely encountered intimidating terrain. The winding roads. The steep hills. The intricate routes that challenge any seasoned driver, and, most recently, advanced cruise control systems that aim to improve fuel efficiency and driver comfort.   Related Articles – Four ways A.I. can help cut

Four ways A.I. can help cut diesel fuel costs

The fluctuation of fuel prices has made it more challenging to operate day-to-day. Drivers get paid by the mile, and, when fuel costs go up, margins shrink, impacting how fleets profit and pay their employees. Intelligent technology can lessen the impact of high prices by improving overall fuel efficiency. Related Articles – New ways to

Peterbilt GM Jason Skoog charts today’s truck support, tomorrow’s truck solutions

Peterbilt made headlines recently when it became the first major North American OEM to open orders for an electric truck, the Peterbilt 220EV. In this exclusive interview, Peterbilt General Manager and PACCAR Vice President Jason Skoog details the technology investments that are keeping fleets productive during this year’s trying pandemic and laying the groundwork for

Peterbilt General Manager PACCAR Technology Electric Truck

Other Posts

Scania opens orders for autonomous mining trucks

Scania’s 40-tonne autonomous heavy tipper for mining available to order, and the 50-tonne model to follow shortly afterwards.

FTR: Truck orders exceed recent trends in May; vocational sales stand out

Not only are orders up m/m and y/y, FTR said this level is above recent demand trends and 2% above the average for May over the past decade.

PACCAR MX-13 CARB compliant engine available in Peterbilt 579, 567, 589

The PACCAR MX-13 diesel engine meets the CARB Omnibus Regulation and is available in high performance or efficiency focused ratings.

Cummins, PACCAR, Daimler Truck N.A. complete joint venture formation

The completed joint venture is now known as Amplify Cell Technologies.