Some fuel economy thoughts

Some fuel economy thoughts

Years ago, Cummins engine tech people said to “gear fast; run slow.” With today’s electronic controls, this is much more do-able than in the past. I believe I would spec the engines with the longest stroke and the tallest (low numerical ratio) rear axle ratio for interstate usage to optimize fuel economy.

I walked by an idling diesel pickup truck going to the store the other day. When I came out some 12 minutes later, the truck was still sitting there idling. If I were a cop, I would have given “Bubba” a ticket and required him to attend a TMC meeting.

I made several observations during a 1,800-mi. highway trip recently. The larger fleet operators tend to drive as slow as practical because they understand the relationship between fuel economy and speed. The smaller fleet drivers and independents tended to “haul the mail!”

The worst offender I noted was a cattle hauler running 80 MPH, essentially dragging a parachute. I’ll bet the more conservative drivers get double the fuel economy he was getting. I wonder if he realizes (or cares) what his fast driving costs both his operation and others’ opinions of truckers. He needs to attend a TMC meeting, also.

It’s interesting to note how many trucks are now utilizing aerodynamic aids. I saw many side skirts and a few aero aids designed to destroy vortices at the rear of trailers. Now I’m wondering why trucks don’t utilize “nose cones” to further improve fuel economy. Any aerodynamicist will tell you how important it is to divert the flow of the air around the sides of the vehicle. Look at faired motorcycles, Bonneville salt flats racers and modern automobiles for examples. An aerodynamic vehicle is much less speed sensitive than a box

Engine speeds (RPMs) of the trucks I passed were also much lower than in the past. Since any engine is essentially an air pump, the slower it can be operated, the better the fuel economy. It has to do with minimizing pumping losses. Diesels are better than gas burners, but both obey the same principles of physics.

Let me validate both of the above points. At one time, I was passed by a Toyota Prius going 85 MPH. I began to wonder the effect of his high RPM on fuel economy, so when I got back home, I did a little research. According to fuel economy test results I found, vehicles with smaller engines that get more than 40 MPG at 55 MPH got around 30 MPG at 75 MPH. The average MPG drop at 75 MPH was 29%. All vehicles tested lost between 11 to 14 MPG at 75 MPH. Small engines must rev very high to produce sufficient power to propel them at 75 MPH. Their fuel systems are probably into power enrichment modes.

Since I had 1,800 mi. of interstate to traverse, I decided to conduct a fuel economy test on my vehicle, because it is very aerodynamic, and the engine speed is only 2,000 RPM at 80 MPH. The numbers tabulated below are the result of two determinations of at least 160 mi. each at a given speed, since modern fuel tanks are so difficult to fill repeatedly.

Run lengths of the 77 MPH and 82 MPH determinations were at least 300 mi.

Although less than a truly scientific experiment, these results indicate that an aerodynamic vehicle utilizing lower engine speeds is less than half as speed sensitive as a vehicle that isn’t designed to run this fast. Shows how important proper truck spec’ing can be, doesn’t it? Okay, I know I broke the law, but a scientist must have data, and if I had driven 55 MPH, I would have been run over!

Years ago, Cummins engine tech people said to “gear fast; run slow.” With today’s electronic controls, this is much more do-able than in the past. I believe I would spec the engines with the longest stroke and the tallest (low numerical ratio) rear axle ratio for interstate usage to optimize fuel economy.

You May Also Like

Commercial tire market cautiously recovering from 2023 challenges

To better understand commercial tire expectations for the remainder of the year, we spolke with Pierluigi Cumo, VP of B2B products at Michelin North America.

Michelin-truck-tires

Despite a tough commercial tire market in 2023 due to overstock and and the effects of a rubber-banding supply chain, some tire manufacturers are expressing a cautious optimism for stabilization and gradual recovery through the rest of 2024 and into 2025. North American fleets are focusing their efforts on operational efficiency and profitability amidst lower shipping rates.

Phillips takes two awards at Penske Supplier Conference

Phillips Industries was awarded both the 2023 Best Performing Supplier – Components Award, and the 2023 Best Innovation Supplier Award.

Phillips-two-awards-2024-penske-supplier-conference-600
SAF-Holland to build specialty fifth wheel manufacturing plant

After nearly 50 years and 3 million fifth wheels produced, SAF-HOLLAND will move production from Wylie, TX to the new facility, once complete.

SAF-HOLLAND-TX-fifth-wheel-plant-rendering
Dayton Parts offers new aftermarket products for Freightliner, Mack, Cummins and Hino applications

A new DPF differential pressure sensor, engine oil dipsticks and fuel injector wiring harnesses designed to match OEM spec.

Dayton-parts-releases-2-sensor-dipstick-harnesses
K&M Tire hires new executive vice president

In his new role, Jon Zurcher is expected to work with current leadership to strengthen and build on the company’s strategic plans.

KM-tire-Logo

Other Posts

Why fuel filtration science matters

Fleetguard shares the story of filtration science leading to a biodiesel solution with a seven-time increase in performance.

The trucking life of the internal combustion engine going forward

A glimpse into the fossil-free future of truck engines that run on everything from biodiesel to natural gas to hydrogen.

volvo-fuel-cell-1400
Bendix: Air disc brake production has doubled since 2018

Commercial ADB adoption rates in Class 6-8 vehicles are now up over 50% according to Bendix.

Bendix-Bowling-Green-ADB-air-disc-brake-doubling-production
East introduces new flatbed floor, tie down system

East says the new design results in a 10% increase in strength under a distributed load and 30% increase under a concentrated load.

East-Manufacturing-tie-down-system-new-flatbed-floor