The ethanol has hit the fan

The ethanol has hit the fan

In June I wrote a column explaining that the world is beginning to question its enthusiastic embrace of ethanol produced from corn.

In June I wrote a column explaining that the world is beginning to question its enthusiastic embrace of ethanol produced from corn. One of our readers commented that I was being unfair to corn-based ethanol because I blamed it for the rise in food prices when there were other market factors at play.

He was absolutely correct –– there are many market factors at play, and no one can say exactly how much of the increase in food, cattle feed, clothing and transportation costs is due to the use of corn-based ethanol. But it has a significant effect.

The reader and I both agree that corn-based ethanol is not a good long-term biofuel because it interferes with our cattle and human food supplies. In Missouri the 10 percent ethanol mandate has been at least partially responsible for a doubling of cattle and chicken food prices over the last two years.

One large chicken feeding operation recently announced it will cease operations because it can no longer sustain profitability. Cattle are now being fed grass instead of corn, and that may actually be a benefit since the meat will be leaner. But my guess is the meat yield will be decreased significantly.

I might also mention I took an ex-tended trip recently in the old family truckster. The Missouri-mandated 10 percent ethanol blend caused a 5 percent fuel economy penalty over straight gasoline. This 1.2 mile-per-gallon decrease agreed exactly with my theoretical calculations. I suppose the real issue here is: Does the re-duced mileage due to 10 percent ethanol more than offset the reduced cost of fuel?

Do any of you recall the late Warren Zevon’s song, “Lawyers, Guns, and Money”? The second line of the song states “the **** has hit the fan.” Missouri’s 10 percent ethanol mandate is sparking investigations into the ethics of the governor, his brother, and his congressman uncle. Alleged-ly, they influenced Missourians to accept the mandate so the politician’s brother, who was heavily invested in ethanol plants, could prosper.

The politician has decided not to run for reelection. The two candidates who are now running for his job have taken opposing views on ethanol. One candidate wants to support the status quo. The opponent wants to open an investigation into the ethics of the politician and his uncle –– and also prefers a repeal of the 10 percent ethanol mandate so that Missouri’s economy can rebound from the deleterious effects of high corn prices. The ethanol has hit the fan!

Corn-based ethanol supporters say that rising farm/food prices are due to increased fuel costs, not rising corn costs. I’m sure that rising diesel costs are a factor here, just like they are in trucking. But if fuel costs are solely responsible for food cost increases, why haven’t the prices for vegetables and meat risen as high? I’ve often heard this argument proposed by several government agencies in support of our federal biofuels legislation, but the facts do not support the conclusion.

Corn-based ethanol supporters also argue that increased exports of corn to other countries is responsible for the high feed and food prices. Again, the facts don’t support the conclusion. It is true that our exports of all farm products are up 25 percent over last year. This is probably driven by the decreasing value of our currency.  But vegetable and meat prices haven’t increased significantly, while corn prices have gone through the roof.

As I’ve stated previously, the longer-term ethanol solution is to produce ethanol from cellulose or other waste materials. I just hope our scientists are given sufficient re-sources to accomplish this quickly.  The 2008 federal ethanol mandate is already requiring 1/4 to 1/3 of the corn we produce. We cannot continue to rely on corn-based ethanol without significantly hampering our economy.  

You May Also Like

Goodyear unveils two RangeMax tires deisgned for regional work

Goodyear says the new tire models balance traction, range and mileage for work vehicles running on electricity, gas or diesel.

Goodyear-rangemax tires-group-logo

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. introduced two additions to its portfolio of RangeMax tires: the RangeMax RSA ULT and the RangeMax RTD ULT. Goodyear says its latest RangeMax tires are a steer-drive combo engineered for electric, gas- or diesel-powered regional work vehicles.

Goodyear says the all-position RangeMax RSA ULT and RangeMax RTD ULT tires help deliver range efficiency through low rolling resistance and long miles to removal. 

Vipar Heavy Duty’s Supplier Advisory Council reviews performance, strategy

The council is expecting a stable aftermarket with moderate growth, a reliable supply chain and continued expansion of VIPAR Heavy Duty in 2024.

vipar-heavy-duty-supplier-advisory-council
Davco introduces Fuel Pro 499 for Class 8 trucks

The company says its latest diesel fuel/water separator was designed to increase filtration capacity and reduce fleet downtime.

DAVCO-fuel-pro-499-water-separator-filter-TMC-Clarience-Technologies
PACCAR Parts presents Dealer of the Year awards at Kenworth Dealer Meeting

Dealer of the Year awards were given out for both TRP and Kenworth parts and service dealers.

PACCAR-Parts-dealer-of-the-year-Kenworth-Northeast-group
Double Coin FR610, other tires to be displayed at MATS

The FR610 is the latest SmartWay Verified long haul steer tire in Double Coin’s lineup.

Double-coin-logo-truck-tire-generic

Other Posts

Dorman announces new light- and heavy-duty aftermarket parts

The company says it released more than 200 light-and heavy-duty aftermarket parts in February, developed for technicians and DIY customers.

Dorman-new-parts
Hendrickson launches Roadmaax Z with ‘Zero Maintenance Damping’

Hendrickson says this is the first drive axle suspension system its released with integrated ZMD technology.

HENDRICKSON-ROADMAAX-Z-SUSPENSION
Lincoln Electric launches Ranger Air 260 MPX multi-function engine drive

Lincoln Electric recently introduced the new Ranger Air 260MPX multifunction engine drive.

Clean Energy’s RNG digester at Tri-Cross Dairy begins production

RNG from the $34M project will be sent to Clean Energy’s network of fueling stations across the U.S.

Clean-Energy-RNG-Facility-Tri-Cross-Dairy