Air suspensions vs. spring suspensions

The ups and downs of air spring, leaf spring truck suspensions

Truck-Lite LED light

Every truck suspension option comes with its own unique performance trade-offs. The best choice requires an understanding of how the trade-offs match up to your application requirements.
The right suspension can maintain a tractor-trailer’s road handling and ride quality, and helps minimize the amount of jarring (bumps, vibrations) for improved load-carrying ability. This protects both the trailer and the freight inside from being damaged, and also cushions the chassis from road shock, enabling the driver to steer. The right suspension also maintains the proper axle spacing and alignment.

To help you decide what will work best for you, let’s walk through the basics of the two most common suspensions used in trucking: air ride and leaf spring.

Air ride systems

Air ride uses a variety of valves, airlines and air-spring bags in place of steel suspension. The flexible air-spring bags are made from a woven and rubber-like material. The air supplied to the air-ride suspension uses the same air compressor and air reservoir as a truck’s braking system (See Figure 1).

The supplied air pressurizes the air-spring bags, creating a spring-like motion that raises the chassis from the axle. Air suspensions are more complicated but often provide a smoother ride and keep sensitive cargo for getting damaged. Using air ride can also make unhooking trailers much easier by using the dump valve to lower the truck enough to pull away from the trailer. But if air ride is used on a dump application you must release air pressure before lifting the bed due to the fact that the dump bed at full height will sway back and forth and could tip over.

Leaf spring systems

Spring suspensions use semi-elliptic leaf springs to cushion a load from road shock. As one of the most commonly used suspensions, spring ride consists of several layers of flexible steel strips referred to as a “leaf pack.”

The strips are joined together to act as a single unit. The long and narrow arch-shaped plates are attached to the frame of a trailer, resting above the trailer’s axle. (See Figure 2)

Spring suspensions are sometimes a harsher ride but are often less expensive to repair due to their simple nature. Spring suspensions are generally used for more heavy duty applications where ride isn’t as important and the cargo is not as sensitive (construction, refuse, off road etc.)

With all of the choices on the market, finding the best suspension for your operation can be a daunting task. It’s best to seek expert advice rather than go it alone. Ask for input from a respected sales professional with specific expertise in suspension applications. Make sure they know exactly under what conditions the truck will be operating, and inform them what you are hoping to spend on operational cost. Lastly, try to get feedback from other fleet or maintenance managers who do similar work—ask them what they use and why.

This article was contributed by Kurt Schneider, technical editor for Mitchell 1’s Commercial Vehicle Group. Additional tips for repair and maintenance of Class 4-8 trucks can be found in the Mitchell 1 ShopConnection Truck blog.

You May Also Like

EUFMC releases conference speaker lineup

Fleet managers can unite at this year’s EUFMC, June 4-7.

With the 2023 EUFMC set to begin in early June, the conference educational program Driving Safety, Sustainability & Technical Expertise continues to take shape. Plans for presentations by fleet executives, manufacturers and industry experts during the two-day General Session include:

Keynote address

Brian L. Wolff, Chief Strategy Officer & Executive Vice President, Public Policy and External Affairs, Edison Electric Institute

Overall new equipment business volume down slightly Y/Y

According to ELFA findings, total headcount for equipment finance companies was down 4.6% year-over-year.

Growth rate of parts aftermarket sales continues to gradually decelerate

CMVC’s Parts Aftermarket Sales Leading Indicator signals slowing growth in commercial vehicle parts sales.

Eight fleets selected to participate in NACFE’s electrification initiative

The transition to electric vehicles is about much more than just the trucks themselves. It is about charging, infrastructure and more.


Other Posts

Reyco Granning offers new suspensions suited for electric vehicles

Reyco Granning develops customizable EV suspension for trucks and buses.

Managing wheel-end PMs to reduce unforeseen service events

Trailer service pop quiz: Do you consider inspections “maintenance”? Answer: Maybe you should, according to Greg Dvorchak, Engineering Supervisor – Brake and Wheel-End Division, Hendrickson. “Inspection is maintenance,” says Dvorchak. From his perspective, service needs and preventive maintenance are two different things. Preventive maintenance is done to extend intervals between service or avoid unplanned wheel-end

Reyco Granning releases second-generation ResponseMaster truck suspension

The company says the second-generation ResponseMaster includes improved air springs and military-derived shock absorbers.

Optimizing your electrical system spring maintenance schedule 

The seven-way connection is the most prone area to the onset of corrosion.