Why are service costs going up when more data means better decisions?

Why are service costs going up when more data means better decisions?

The five most frequent repairs in Q1 2018 included tires, lighting, brakes, exhaust systems and wheels/rims/hubs and bearing systems.

Unscheduled roadside repairs. 

Three words you hear too often, at least according to the results of ATA’s Technology and Maintenance Council (TMC) and FleetNet America benchmarking study that took a deep dive into the frequency of roadside failures among truckload fleets. The executive summary from the 2018 Q4 report stated that, on average, a roadside maintenance event occurred every 10,663 miles between Oct. to Dec. 2018. Additionally, the report found that the average cost per mechanical repair in that same time period was $334.20 per repair—the highest it had ever been since the quarterly benchmarking project started a year ago.

As a fleet service manager, those numbers might make your stomach churn, but if you’re being honest with yourself, it’s because you’ve likely faced those costs. The five most frequent repairs in Q1 2018 included tires, lighting, brakes, exhaust systems and wheels/rims/hubs and bearing systems. These five repairs accounted for 37% of all roadside repairs in Q4 2017 and increased to 58% of all unscheduled repairs.

“We’re measuring miles between breakdowns and miles between repairs,” explained Jim Buell, executive vice president of sales and marketing for FleetNet America. “A breakdown is when the asset is on the side of the road, but there could be more than one repair to get that asset back on the road. When you look at miles between repairs, it helps you make better decisions. And with breakdowns, it costs more to fix something on the side of the road. I believe understanding your roadside failures gives you great insight into your maintenance operation.”

The best-in-class fleet in the truckload vertical ran seven times longer between roadside failures than the vertical average with a total of 75,528 miles between unscheduled roadside repairs. How does your service operation stack up?  

Buell explained that the TMC/FleetNet America benchmarking program aims to help TMC members drive down maintenance costs. Avoiding roadside repairs is a major component of that, as on average it costs four times more to repair a truck on the side of the road vs. fixing it in your shop. 

Buell detailed the VMRS-based benchmarking, which compares the industry average maintenance practices and costs to your specific fleet’s performance. 

“It will tell you how many repairs you had by VMRS system,” he said. “It’ll tell you how many miles you ran between repairs and compare that to the vertical average. Then to make it really easy, it will also tell you how much more it’s costing you to perform below the industry average or how much you’re saving by performing above the average.”

He pointed to a screen displaying rows and columns of service data that is available to TMC members and powered by FleetNet America’s back end solutions. The line he called out is a fleet’s maintenance cost related to wheels, rims and bearings.

“In this particular case,” he began excitedly, “this fleet is ahead $42,000 on wheel, rim and bearing maintenance costs. With that, if I’m that fleet, I might go upstairs to senior management and say, ‘Hey, we’re better than the industry average, and I saved the company $42,000.’” 

Wouldn’t we all love to have an awesome line-item savings to point to?

If you’re interested in joining the program and gaining access to the benchmarking data to see how your service operation, visit benchmarkit.fleetnetamerica.com for more details.

You May Also Like

ISEE fully autonomous truck yard up and running

ISEE claims the autonomous truck yard will be help improve safety, efficiency and staffing concerns.


ISEE, a manufacturer of autonomous vehicle technology for transportation and logistics, announced that it deployed a commercial fleet of autonomous yard trucks at a Fortune 100 customer’s site in Texas. ISEE did not name the customer.

According to ISEE, the autonomous trucks operate through AI, machine learning, and computer vision, and are able to function day and night, rain or shine. The company adds that the trucks not only streamline movements of trailers and containers throughout the yard, but they also give companies staffing predictability amidst labor shortages. You can see how it works in the video below.

Geotab introduces new fleet safety tools

Geotab Safety Center and Enhanced Collision Detection are among the new offerings for 2024.

Daimler, Linde to provide new liquid hydrogen refueling process

The companies say the process is safe, fast and simple, adding that it can of deliver 175 pounds of liquid hydrogen in 10-15 minutes.

Carrier Logistics automates residential delivery scheduling

LTL carriers now have a text-integrated customer-centric solution for managing a growing number of residential deliveries.

Geotab introduces routing and dispatching solution

The tool can use data such as requested arrival windows, traffic data and available fleet resources to plan optimal routes.

Other Posts

FE’s February Fab 5 truck trends

Maintenance vs. buying new: We weigh the costly pros and cons of keeping your fleet running.

Decisiv truck service trends: Service activity rises y/y, m/m as AMT service increases

We’re continuing the truck service trends conversation, focusing on Q3 2023 service activity.

Leonard’s Express opts for Isaac Instruments telematics

The refrigerated carrier says it felt current safety technology had grown “stagnant,” and formed this partnership to better serve drivers.

Geotab announces 2024 Innovation Award winners

Twelve winners were named in five categories, including new nomination-based awards.