Truck diagnostics: Don’t jump to the wrong conclusion

Truck diagnostics: Don’t jump to the wrong conclusion

It’s a lot like déjà vu. For technicians who are fortunate enough to maintain a fleet of similarly-equipped vehicles, it comes as no surprise when they see the same fault codes and failures occurring on those vehicles.

Typically, there are a limited number of potential codes that ever set, even though some vehicle systems have the capability of setting hundreds of different fault codes. On one hand, having a limited quantity of recurring problems is good news, as this enables the technician to quickly gain an understanding of what fails frequently and how to correct the problem.

On the other hand, a downside may rear its ugly head. What in the world could be the downside to recognizing a common problem area and knowing how to fix it? The answer is over-familiarity — a presumed understanding that a particular problem is always the result of a specific set of circumstances.

Truck Diagnostics Don’t jump to the wrong conclusion

The danger of diagnostic assumptions

Let’s take a look at how a diagnostic assumption can lead to a misdiagnosis and result in increased costs and downtime.

There is no question that being familiar with a fault code—both the cause and correction—can be a great timesaver for the technician. After all, some diagnostic procedures can take a lot of time and effort as the technician works through the diagnostic steps to systematically eliminate potential issues. By knowing where the fault generally occurs, the technician can go directly there without going through all the steps that lead to that problem point. But, this can be risky.

Unfortunately, there are times when fixing the assumed problem does not correct the actual issue on that particular vehicle. Then what? Labor and parts have been expended without fixing the problem. At this point, the tech starts working through the step-by-step diagnostic procedure, and the downtime clock keeps on ticking.

Another drawback to jumping to conclusions with diagnostics is that while the repair may correct the problem, the cause of the problem may be completely overlooked. A hypothetical example: When fault code XYZ sets, replacing the sensor corrects the fault code setting—but what is missed is why the sensor failed. Are the wires damaged by heat creating too much resistance? Is there excessive heat on the sensor? Does moisture get in the connector, causing corrosion which gets temporarily cleaned off with the new sensor?

There is no doubt that knowing failure patterns and the typical fix can provide a great head start in diagnosing a problem. This is especially true if the problem spot is not easily determined. Nevertheless, it is important to not simply abandon proper diagnostic procedures by jumping to a conclusion based solely on past experience, gut feeling or advice.

There may be many reasons why a failure occurred. Making the effort to better understand the “why” behind the failure can be more crucial than determining what failed. Without addressing the “why,” the “what” may very well turn into that familiarity paradigm where we keep replacing the same part over and over again. It’s a lot like déjà vu.

Additional tips for repair and maintenance of Class 4-8 trucks may be found in the Mitchell 1 ShopConnection Truck blog.

You May Also Like

Women In Trucking Association announces September 2023 Member of the Month

Duryea is the director of Driver Recruitment and Professional Growth at Boyle Transportation, a transportation logistics provider.

The Women In Trucking Association (WIT) has announced Laura Duryea as its September 2023 Member of the Month. Duryea is the director of Driver Recruitment and Professional Growth at Boyle Transportation, a specialized transportation logistics provider, the press release notes.

According to the association, Duryea got her start in the transportation industry as a professional driver which was inspired by driving the shuttle bus while attending Carnegie Mellon University. After graduating with a Viola Performance degree and a change of heart, she decided to attend Pittsburgh Diesel Institute, resulting in a 25-year driving career.

FMCSA removes Falcon ELD, KSK ELD from list of registered devices

Beginning November 13, 2023, motor carriers who continue to use the revoked devices listed above will be considered to be operating without an ELD.

Phillips Industries announces promotions, strategic restructure 

In addition to their promotions, White and Forthoffer have restructured their marketing and R&D teams to now serve all business units within the Phillips Family.

Arnold Motor Supply acquires Barron Motor Supply

Arnold Motor Supply and Barron Motor Supply recently announced their merger, both companies marking nearly a century in the industry.

70th Annual EUFMC event planning begins

Invited professionals can expect to begin receiving registration information by email this fall for the event.

Other Posts

Trucking Sustainably: What do we do with all of these batteries?

The batteries that propel the electric truck powertrains of the future will have to go somewhere. Here’s Volvo’s plan.

Five truck trend takeaways from September

Let’s rewind and explore the pages of our industry playbook in this truck trends takeaway, just like the pros in the NFL. Run it back!

Twin Rivers Unified School District fields one of the largest electric school bus fleets

The fleet’s lower prices and operating costs are coupled with the sustainability benefits.

The benefits of ‘coopetition’ in the heavy-duty market

Industry players are aligning with diverse objectives and forging partnerships that tap into various CV segments.